← Market Briefs · Choice of America
San Diego County: How to Buy a Home You Plan to Rent Short-Term: City STRO License Limits, the Proposed Nightly Housing Fee, Hotel Tax and the Lender Math (November 2026)
The City of San Diego is considering a nightly affordable housing fee on short-term rentals, as much as $8.33 in Mission Beach. Here's how to check license limits, hotel tax, and lender math before you buy.
Many buyers in San Diego have the same idea: buy a place near the beach, in North Park or downtown, rent it out by the night when you're not using it, and let the guests help pay the mortgage. Sometimes that works. Often the numbers, the city rules or the loan rules get in the way, and buyers find out after they've closed.
This week the City of San Diego took a step that could change those numbers. On Friday, November 20, the City Council's Land Use and Housing Committee heard an updated study supporting a new nightly affordable housing fee on short-term rentals. The study puts the maximum fee at $2.38 a night in most of the city and as much as $8.33 a night in Mission Beach. The committee's action asks staff to draft a fee proposal for the full City Council. No fee has been adopted yet.
That's one more cost on top of rules many buyers don't know about: the city caps whole-home licenses, a license doesn't transfer to a new owner, there's a 90-night minimum to keep a whole-home license, and guests pay a hotel tax of 11.75% to 13.75%. This guide explains the rules in plain English, runs the numbers on a real example, shows how lenders count short-term rental income, and walks through how to check a specific home before you make an offer.
What's in the news
- A nightly housing fee on short-term rentals moves forward (Nov. 20). The City Council District 6 office (Council President Pro Tem Kent Lee) and the San Diego Housing Commission presented an update of the city's 2018 nexus study, prepared by Keyser Marston Associates (KMA). According to the staff report, the proposed action is to have District 6 work with the Housing Commission, the City Attorney, the City Treasurer and the Independent Budget Analyst to "draft a recommendation for City Council to establish an Affordable Housing Impact Fee related to short-term residential occupancy, including a proposed fee schedule." The report says the fee could take the form of "a nightly fee paid by the visitor." The meeting tracker ZoneWire reports that the committee recommended the item unanimously on a motion by Kent Lee. (Vote from ZoneWire's summary; the city's official minutes were not reviewed.)
- What the study found. KMA's maximum supportable nightly fees for whole-home rentals are $7.73 in La Jolla, $8.33 in Mission Beach, $6.64 in Pacific Beach, $5.34 in Mission Valley, $5.24 in Southeastern/Encanto, $3.62 in Ocean Beach/Point Loma, $3.46 in North Park and $2.38 downtown. For home sharing (renting a room while you live there), the maximums are $4.03 (high-market) and $2.49 (mid-market). The method: KMA estimates how many lower-wage jobs (cleaners, maintenance workers, restaurant and retail staff) visitor spending creates, compares that with the same home used as a regular residence, and spreads the difference over 55 years and 365 nights.
- The fee structure District 6 asked KMA to model. Separate maximum fees in the three highest submarkets (La Jolla, Mission Beach and Pacific Beach) and a uniform $2.38 fee everywhere else. KMA's revenue sheet, based on city license data for July 2024 through June 2025, estimates that structure would raise about $4.56 million a year from about 953,555 booked nights across 5,733 whole-home licenses that had bookings. That assumes the maximum fee on every night and no change in bookings.
- It's happened before. The staff report notes that in 2018 the council adopted a nightly fee of $2.73 for home sharing and $3.96 for whole homes, but it was repealed later that year after a referendum petition against the city's short-term rental ordinances. Under the city's current ordinance, operating a short-term rental without a license has been unlawful since May 1, 2023.
- Whole-home licenses are close to the cap. The City Treasurer's short-term residential occupancy (STRO) page, updated November 17, shows that as of November 6, 2026, the city had issued 4,863 Tier 3 whole-home licenses with 798 remaining, and 1,099 Tier 4 Mission Beach licenses with 0 remaining (the Mission Beach waitlist application period is closed). Total licenses issued: 8,428.
- Elsewhere in the county this week. The County Board of Supervisors approved phase one of its "Housing Unlocked" zoning changes for the unincorporated area, which removes story limits (while keeping height limits), explicitly allows prefabricated and 3D-printed homes, and allows smaller minimum lots through the review process, according to a county news report (November 20). The board also approved an application for up to $1.5 million in state Prohousing Incentive funds for the county's Down Payment Assistance Program, which makes low-interest, deferred-payment loans to households earning 80% to 120% of area median income (a county news report, November 18).
The October 2026 market snapshot (San Diego County)
| Measure | October 2026 | Change from a year earlier |
|---|---|---|
| Median listing price | $889,000 | −4.1% (October 2025: about $927,000) |
| Active listings | 5,735 | +9.7% |
| New listings | 2,140 | −28.0% |
| Pending listings | 1,888 | −15.2% |
| Median days on market | 48 | +2.1% |
| Share of listings with a price cut | 20.5% | +2.3 points (October 2025: about 18.2%) |
| Median price per square foot | $583 | −3.7% |
Source: public housing-market data, county core metrics, San Diego County, October 2026, the latest month available as of November 21, 2026. The 20.5% price-cut share is a major listing portal's own price-cut share, not a count of reduced listings divided by active listings.
Closed sales tell a slightly different story. A statewide housing-market report on November 17 said that San Diego County's October median sold price for existing single-family homes was $1,037,000, up 5.3% from a year earlier, while closed sales fell 22.2%. The county's Unsold Inventory Index rose to 3.6 months, from 2.9 months a year earlier, and the median time on market was 23 days. A statewide sales report measures closed sales of single-family homes and a major listing portal measures all listings, so their medians differ.
What a median-priced listing costs at today's rate. A national mortgage-rate survey's 30-year fixed average was 7.28% on November 19, 2026, up from 7.11% a week earlier. A year ago (November 20, 2025) it was 6.26%. With 20% down ($177,800) on the $889,000 median, the loan is $711,200. At 7.28%, principal and interest come to about $4,866 a month. A year ago, 20% down on about $927,000 at 6.26% meant a $741,600 loan and about $4,571 a month. Add property tax at an assumed 1.1% total rate (about $815 a month) and $150 a month for insurance, and the total is about $5,831 a month. With 10% down ($88,900), principal and interest are about $5,474; with 5% down ($44,450), about $5,779. (Illustration only. Not a loan quote. The 1.1% tax rate and $150 insurance figure are assumptions. Mortgage insurance and HOA dues are not included. A national mortgage-rate survey reflects primary-residence borrowers; investment-property rates are usually higher.)
In plain terms: more listings, more price cuts and fewer pending sales mean buyers have room to negotiate. Before you count on nightly rental income to make a payment like that work, you need to know whether you can get a license, what it will really earn, and how your lender will count it.
How short-term rental rules work in the City of San Diego
These rules apply to homes inside the City of San Diego (its nine council districts). Other cities in the county, including Oceanside, Carlsbad, Encinitas, Coronado, Del Mar and Solana Beach, and the unincorporated county set their own rules. Check the city that actually governs the address.
- Any stay under one month needs a license. The city requires a Short-Term Residential Occupancy (STRO) license to rent a home, or part of one, for less than a month. There are four tiers:
- Tier 1 (part-time): whole-home rentals totaling 20 days or less a year. You don't have to live there. No cap.
- Tier 2 (home sharing): renting a room or rooms for more than 20 days a year while you live on-site. You can also rent the whole home while you're away for up to 90 days a year. The home must be your permanent residence (the city's FAQ describes this as living there at least 275 days a year). No cap.
- Tier 3 (whole home, outside Mission Beach): more than 20 days a year when you don't live on-site. Capped at 1% of the city's housing units outside Mission Beach.
- Tier 4 (Mission Beach whole home): capped at 30% of housing units in the Mission Beach community planning area.
- There's a gap in the middle. The city's FAQ says whole-home rentals of 21 to 89 days a year aren't allowed if you don't live there. Above 20 days you need Tier 3 or 4, and those licenses require you to rent the home at least 90 days a year and file quarterly reports. The ordinance has no exception for slow seasons or cancellations, and missing the minimum puts the license at risk of revocation.
- One license per person, and it doesn't come with the house. A host can hold only one license and operate only one STRO in the city at a time. Licenses are not transferable between owners or locations. If you buy a home that's operating as a vacation rental today, the seller's license does not become yours. You'd have to apply yourself, and in Mission Beach there are currently no Tier 4 licenses available.
- Fees. Application and license fees for a two-year license are $33 + $193 (Tier 1), $33 + $284 (Tier 2) and $41 + $1,129 (Tiers 3 and 4). They're non-refundable, and renewals cost the same.
- Operating rules. Tier 3 and Tier 4 rentals have a two-night minimum stay. Each STRO must have a local contact, and the city's complaint process expects that contact to respond within one hour. Neighbors can report violations to the city's Building and Land Use Enforcement team.
- Hotel tax (TOT). Guests staying less than a month owe the city's Transient Occupancy Tax. Since May 1, 2025 (Measure C), the rate is 11.75%, 12.75% or 13.75% depending on which of three tax zones the property is in. You need a free Transient Occupancy Registration Certificate before you apply for a license. The tax is collected from guests along with the rent and must be sent to the city monthly, by the last day of the following month. Late payments carry a penalty of 1% for the first day plus one-third of 1% per day after that, up to 25%. Ask whether your booking platform collects and remits the city's TOT for you. If it doesn't, you have to.
- Business taxes. Owners renting a property also owe the city's annual Rental Unit Business Tax (a base fee plus a per-unit fee). Hosts who don't own the home need a Business Tax Certificate ($34 a year for 12 or fewer employees).
- The possible new fee. If the council adopts the affordable housing impact fee, the staff report describes it as a nightly fee paid by the visitor. (The 2018 fee was to be charged on each nightly rental and remitted monthly to the City Treasurer.) Your guests would pay it, but it raises the total price of each stay, and you'd have to collect and remit it.
Two more rules sit outside the city code:
- HOAs can ban short stays. California Civil Code §4741 generally stops homeowners associations from banning rentals, but it specifically allows an HOA to prohibit rentals of 30 days or less. Many condo and townhome associations do. Read the CC&Rs and rules before you count on any nightly income.
- Lenders have their own rules. These are covered in the next section.
Run the numbers
The examples below use figures from the city's own data and the KMA study. Every assumption is labeled. They're illustrations, not predictions or loan quotes.
Illustration 1: How much does a two-bedroom house in North Park earn? KMA's study lists short-term rental market data from May 2026. For single-family homes in North Park, the average two-bedroom nightly rate was $239 and average occupancy was 71%. At those numbers, the home would earn about $61,937 a year ($239 × 365 × 71%), or about $5,161 a month, before any costs.
The city's own booking records are less optimistic. KMA's revenue sheet shows 953,555 nights booked across 5,733 whole-home licenses with bookings (July 2024 through June 2025). That's an average of about 166 nights a year, roughly 46% of the year. At $239 a night, 166 nights brings in about $39,674 a year, or $3,306 a month. That occupancy figure is a market average for the listings it tracks, while the city figure averages every whole-home license that had bookings, so the two measure different things. Plan with both and be ready for the lower one.
Illustration 2: The purchase and payment. KMA's prototype for a North Park two-bedroom, 950-square-foot house uses a price of $985,000. Suppose you buy it as an investment property with 25% down ($246,250). The loan is $738,750.
- At 7.28%, principal and interest are about $5,055 a month.
- Property tax at an assumed 1.1%: about $903 a month.
- Insurance with short-term rental coverage at an assumed $250 a month.
- Total (PITI): about $6,208 a month.
Investment loans usually cost more than the primary-residence rate in a national mortgage-rate survey. At a hypothetical 8.03% (0.75 point higher), principal and interest are about $5,436 and PITI about $6,589.
Illustration 3: Does it cash-flow? Assume operating costs of 35% of gross rent for cleaning, supplies, utilities, internet, platform fees, repairs and management (an assumption; get real quotes).
- At the study's 71% occupancy: $5,161 gross − $1,806 costs = $3,355 a month before the mortgage. Against PITI of $6,208, that's about $2,853 a month short.
- At the city's 166-night average: $3,306 gross − $1,157 costs = $2,149. That's about $4,059 a month short.
To break even with 35% operating costs, the home would need to average about $442 a night at 71% occupancy, or about $690 a night at 166 nights a year. That's about double the North Park two-bedroom average. In this example, short-term rental income helps with the payment but doesn't cover it at today's rates.
Illustration 4: How a lender counts it. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide has a section on short-term rental income (B3-3.8-03, dated September 2, 2026). For a purchase, the lender uses either a long-term market rent from the appraiser (Form 1007) or validated short-term rental data from three comparable short-term rentals. It then multiplies the monthly gross by 50% to cover vacancy and expenses and subtracts the full payment (PITIA).
- At 71% occupancy: $5,161 × 50% = $2,581, minus $6,208 = −$3,627 a month.
- A negative number like that counts as a debt in your debt-to-income ratio. In this example, the lender would treat the property as costing you about $3,627 a month, even with the rental income.
- For the result to be break-even at 71% occupancy, the comparable rentals would need to average about $575 a night.
Fannie Mae limits this to one-unit investment properties that are legally permitted (licensed and registered) as short-term rentals. Short-term income from an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) can't be used. Fannie's eligibility matrix caps a one-unit investment purchase at 85% loan-to-value (at least 15% down). On this example, 15% down ($147,750) means an $837,250 loan and about $5,729 a month in principal and interest at 7.28%.
Illustration 5: What the proposed fee would add. The fee would be charged to guests, so it doesn't come out of your pocket directly. It does raise the total price guests see.
- $2.38 on a $239 night is about 1%.
- At the city's 166-night average, $2.38 a night totals about $395 a year per home. At 71% occupancy (259 nights), about $617.
- In the higher-fee areas, using each area's average booked nights from KMA's sheet: about $1,185 a year in La Jolla ($7.73 × about 153 nights), $1,441 in Mission Beach ($8.33 × about 173 nights) and $1,102 in Pacific Beach ($6.64 × about 166 nights).
- For comparison, the hotel tax on a $239 night is $28.08 to $32.86, depending on the tax zone.
Illustration 6: The owner-occupant version. If you live in the home, a Tier 2 license lets you rent a room year-round or rent the whole home while you travel for up to 90 days. KMA's study data shows a mid-market home-share room in North Park averaging $91 a night at 60% occupancy. That's about $19,929 a year. Renting a $239-a-night two-bedroom while you're away for 60 nights would bring in about $14,340. For context, $1,000 a month in principal and interest supports about $146,000 of loan at 7.28%. Fannie Mae's short-term rental rules apply only to investment properties, so plan to qualify on your own income and treat this money as extra.
How to buy a home you plan to rent short-term: step by step
- Confirm the jurisdiction. Use the city's council district map to confirm the home is inside the City of San Diego. If it's in another city or the unincorporated county, get that jurisdiction's rules in writing before you go further.
- Find the community planning area and tax zone. Use the city's Community Planning Area map (Mission Beach means Tier 4, with no licenses available now) and the TOT tax zone lookup map (11.75%, 12.75% or 13.75%).
- Check the license count before you write an offer. Look at the "Remaining Licenses Available" table on the STRO page. As of November 6, there were 798 Tier 3 licenses left. Remember the seller's license doesn't transfer. Call STRO Administration at (619) 615-6120 or email stro@sandiego.gov with questions about timing and the application process.
- Pick your tier honestly. If you'll live there, Tier 2 is uncapped. If you won't, you need Tier 3 or 4 and must rent at least 90 nights a year. Whole-home rentals of 21 to 89 days aren't allowed. Don't plan on "a few weeks a year" unless that's 20 days or less (Tier 1).
- Read the HOA documents. Ask for the CC&Rs, rules and any recent amendments. Look for a minimum lease term (often 30 days), registration requirements, guest rules, parking limits and fines. Under Civil Code §4741, a 30-day minimum is allowed.
- Get real rental data, not a seller's spreadsheet. Ask the seller for actual booking history, monthly payouts, TOT returns and STRO quarterly reports. Compare with at least three comparable licensed rentals nearby (nightly rates and days booked). Run the numbers at both a high and a low occupancy, as in Illustration 1.
- Talk to a lender before you shop. Ask whether the lender uses Fannie Mae's short-term rental method, whether it will use validated short-term data or only long-term rent, what down payment it requires (at least 15% for a one-unit investment purchase under Fannie Mae) and what rate it quotes for investment properties. Some borrowers use loans based on the property's cash flow. Compare their rates and prepayment terms carefully.
- Price insurance early. Tell the insurance agent exactly how the home will be used. A standard homeowners policy may not cover paying guests. Get a written quote for short-term rental coverage before you remove contingencies.
- Build a full monthly budget. Include PITI, HOA dues, utilities, internet, cleaning, supplies, furnishing, repairs, platform fees, management (if any), the license and business tax, and a reserve for slow months. Remember that TOT and any new nightly fee are collected from guests but raise their total price.
- Get tax advice. IRS rules for rentals depend on how many days you rent the home and how many you use it yourself (IRS Topic 415 and Publication 527). Talk to a tax professional before you buy, not after.
How to use what you find in your offer
- Make the license an issue to resolve before you commit. If short-term income is part of your plan, give yourself time in the contract to confirm the license tier, the cap, HOA rules and insurance. Your agent can write an investigation contingency that covers these items.
- Don't pay extra for a license you won't get. Some listings are marketed with strong vacation-rental income. Because the license stays with the seller, that income history doesn't come with the house. Value the home as a home, and treat any short-term income as a possible extra.
- Use the market data. About 20.5% of San Diego County listings had a price cut in October, active listings were up 9.7%, and pending sales were down 15.2%. If a home has been sitting, that's leverage.
- Ask for help with the payment. A seller credit to buy down your rate can lower your monthly payment, which matters more than gross rent. Ask your lender to compare a price cut with a rate buydown.
- Plan a fallback. Run the numbers as a long-term rental (30 days or more) or as your own home. If the home only works with short-term income, the risk is high: the fee, the cap or the HOA rules could change.
If you want to be heard on the proposed fee
- Know where it stands. The committee asked staff to draft a recommendation, including a fee schedule and code changes. It still has to go to the full City Council. The staff report says future recommendations will involve coordination with industry stakeholders and host platforms.
- Contact the committee or the council office. The item's contact is Angeli Hoyos, Council District 6, (619) 236-6616. General committee questions go to Council Administration at CouncilCommittee@sandiego.gov or (619) 533-4474.
- Follow updates. Sign up for STRO email updates on the City Treasurer's STRO page and watch the City Council agendas for the item to return.
Mistakes to avoid
- Assuming the license comes with the house. It doesn't.
- Planning on 30 to 80 nights a year as a whole-home rental without living there. In the city, that range isn't allowed.
- Buying in Mission Beach expecting a whole-home license. As of November 6, none were available.
- Ignoring the HOA. A 30-day minimum in the CC&Rs ends the plan.
- Using the best-case occupancy. The city's records show about 166 booked nights a year on average.
- Forgetting how the lender counts the income. At 50% of gross minus the full payment, rental income may still show as a monthly loss on your loan application.
- Treating TOT as optional. It's due monthly, and penalties go up to 25%.
Quick checklist
- Address is inside the City of San Diego (or you have the other city's rules in writing)
- Community planning area and TOT tax zone confirmed
- Tier 3 licenses still available (or Tier 2 if you'll live there)
- HOA allows stays under 30 days
- Seller's booking history, payouts and TOT returns reviewed
- Three comparable licensed rentals checked
- Lender pre-approval that addresses short-term income and investment-property terms
- Written quote for short-term rental insurance
- Monthly budget at high and low occupancy, including a fallback plan
- Tax advice
What this means day to day
For most buyers, the safest version of this idea is the owner-occupant one: buy a home you can afford on your own income, then rent a room or the whole place while you're away with a Tier 2 license. For investors, the City of San Diego is a capped, closely regulated market where the license is personal, the minimum is 90 nights, and a new nightly fee may be coming. At 7.28% rates, short-term income often helps but doesn't cover the payment. Check the rules and run the numbers before you write the offer, not after you close.
Talk to Choice of America
If you're thinking about buying a home in North Park, Pacific Beach, Ocean Beach, La Jolla, downtown or anywhere else in San Diego County and want to know whether short-term rental income is realistic, we can help you check the license rules, review HOA documents, gather comparable rental data and build the numbers into your offer. Call or text 833-THIS-BROKER (833-842-7465), visit https://choiceofamerica.com/, or see our San Diego County page at https://choiceofamerica.com/san-diego-county-real-estate.html.
Dr. Hamid Rowshan, DRE #02004794 | Choice of America, company DRE #02240008
This article is general information, not legal, tax, insurance or lending advice. Short-term rental rules, license counts, fees and tax rates are summarized from City of San Diego Office of the City Treasurer pages, the November 20, 2026 Land Use and Housing Committee staff report and Keyser Marston Associates study materials, and California and Fannie Mae sources as they appeared on November 21, 2026, and may change; confirm with the responsible agency, your HOA and your lender. No affordable housing impact fee has been adopted; the fee amounts are the study's maximum supportable levels, not a final schedule. The committee vote is from ZoneWire's meeting summary; official minutes were not reviewed. AirDNA figures are from the KMA study (May 2026) and are not a forecast for any property. Payment, income and fee figures are illustrations based on stated assumptions (1.1% tax rate, $150 and $250 insurance, 25% down, 35% operating costs, a hypothetical 8.03% investment rate), not loan quotes. Public housing-market figures are countywide asking-price data and are not appraisals of any property. Choice of America is a real estate brokerage, not a law firm, tax adviser, insurer or lender.
Sources: City treasurer and land-use committee materials, a consultant nexus study, public housing-market data, national mortgage-rate surveys, statewide housing-market reports, published local and county news coverage, and published lending guidelines, as of November 21, 2026.
Unconfirmed / pending items: (1) the Nov 20 committee vote (unanimous, moved by Kent Lee) is from ZoneWire, not official minutes; (2) no fee has been adopted, the final fee schedule and timing are unknown, and the full Council has not acted; (3) the $4.56M revenue figure is KMA's maximum-fee scenario, not a forecast.